Thursday, January 22, 2009

Overall or Conference?

This is a debate me and Mykl have been having for which records to use. I personally think it's stupid to not use the overall records because every team plays every team the same amount of times (intra-conference). So what do you guys think, overall or conference?

8 comments:

sizemorematters said...

Mhy vote's for overall, btw.

Big Mike said...

Well I think it goes Best Record, but if the Division Records are tied then the Tiebraker is a H2H. I wil give an example.
say its the end of the year and these are the standings.

1. Pearl City : 9 - 3 (4 - 2)

2. Las Vegas : 9 - 3 (4 - 2)

but say PC beat LV 2wice then they get Home Field for the Conf. Champ. if it is a Complete Tie, then why not play it at a Neutral Site?

If 2 and 3 tie, and H2H is a tie we could have a "Wild Card" Game for them.

sizemorematters said...

What if PC is 7-3, but 6-0 in division, while SA is 8-2, but 4-2 in division. In that case, SA won more games than PC playing the same teams.

sizemorematters said...

I think we should do both conference championships at neutral sites. Some locals could be:

West

San Diego
Los Angeles
Arizona
Houston
Dallas

East

Orlando
Tampa
Miami
New Orleans
Atlanta

Just some ideas.

Beast Mode said...

1st-Overall Record
2nd-Division Record
3rd-H2H

And we should use the Rose Bowl and the Superdome

Big Mike said...

Yes Rosebowl is a good idea, Beast Mode hit the nail right on the Head, Team wit Best Record gets #1 Spot, if they are tied then Div Record, if they are tied on both of those then we look at H2H.

For Neutral Sites, I wanted it that way for the Championship also, cause it really is not fair if Sizmore gets in the Championship, thats not really fair because it is a Home Game, and the other team might have a better record.

West Conf. Championship
Rose Bowl - Los Angeles

East Conf. Championship
Superdome - New Orleans (Since are divisoin is basically smack dab in the South)

Championship
FedEx Field - Washigton D.C. or Arrowhead Stadium - Kansas City, Missori

D.C.is the largest NFL stadium and it's our Nations capitol so I like it, and Arrowhead is a great stadium and its right in between West and East.

If we play Neutral-Site Conf. Champ. games we should do the same for the Champ., NO Homefield Advantage that way.

sizemorematters said...

I wouldn't say Arrowhead or FedEx at this time of year. I'd say Houston, Arizona, or Florida (maybe Orlando since it'll be our one chance to go there).

Beast Mode said...

Maybe even the old Cowboy Stadium